Customise Consent Preferences

We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.

The cookies that are categorised as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. ... 

Always Active

Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.

No cookies to display.

Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.

No cookies to display.

Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.

No cookies to display.

Performance cookies are used to understand and analyse the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.

No cookies to display.

Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customised advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyse the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.

No cookies to display.

7 Best Insurance Companies of USA : Stock Analysis & Views

Stock Analysis of 7 Best Insurance Companies of USA

In this blog we are going to get info and do stock analysis of 7 best Insurance companies of USA. You are going to get most of the Stock Analysis covered in this blog so read it fully.

Let’s first see the overall intro to Insurance sector in USA.

Introduction to the Insurance Sector in the USA

The insurance sector is a critical component of the U.S. economy, providing financial protection against risks for individuals, businesses, and institutions. It includes various segments such as health, life, property & casualty, auto, and reinsurance. The industry plays a vital role in economic stability, risk management, and investment funding.

Contribution to GDP

The insurance sector contributes significantly to the U.S. Gross Domestic Product (GDP). According to industry reports:

  • Insurance carriers and related activities contribute ~3% of the U.S. GDP.
  • The total economic impact is even larger when considering indirect contributions, such as investments made by insurers in various sectors.

Employment & Job Creation

The insurance industry is a major employer in the U.S.:

  • Employs over 2.8 million people directly.
  • Indirectly supports millions of jobs in finance, healthcare, legal, and technology sectors.
  • Careers range from underwriters, actuaries, and claims adjusters to sales agents and financial analysts.

Overall Importance

  1. Financial Security – Protects businesses and individuals from unexpected financial losses.
  2. Economic Stability – Encourages investment by reducing financial risks.
  3. Capital Investment – Insurance companies manage trillions of dollars in assets, investing in real estate, infrastructure, and stock markets.
  4. Disaster Recovery – Provides payouts during natural disasters, accidents, and health crises, helping in economic recovery.

With a strong regulatory framework and increasing demand for risk coverage, the U.S. insurance industry remains one of the most influential and stable sectors in the global economy.

List of 7 Biggest Insurance Companies in the USA with Market Cap :

Here is a table summarizing the 7 major publicly listed U.S. insurance companies, including their stock ticker symbols, stock prices, market capitalizations, and estimated net profits:

CompanyTickerIndex ListedStock Price (USD)Market Capitalization (USD)Net Profit (USD) (Approx.)
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.BRK.ANYSE771,250.001.08 trillion14.5 billion (Q4 2024)
UnitedHealth Group Inc.UNHNYSE488.65451 billion~5.5 billion (Q4 2024)
MetLife Inc.METNYSE80.4156 billion~2.2 billion (Q4 2024)
Prudential Financial Inc.PRUNYSE108.4938 billion~1.8 billion (Q4 2024)
The Progressive CorporationPGRNYSE283.69164 billion2.36 billion (Q4 2024)
The Travelers Companies Inc.TRVNYSE260.9158 billion~1.4 billion (Q4 2024)
Allstate CorporationALLNYSE207.4953 billion~1.6 billion (Q4 2024)

Notes:

  • Stock Prices are as of March 15, 2025.
  • Market Capitalization is based on the latest available data.
  • Net Profit figures are estimated based on recent trends and available reports.

These insurance companies are among the most stable and profitable in the U.S., playing a crucial role in financial services, risk management, and economic stability. 

Fundamental Stock Analysis of 7 Biggest Insurance companies of USA :

Here’s a comparative table of the 7 major publicly listed U.S. insurance companies, including key financial metrics:

CompanyDebt/EquityP/E RatioP/B RatioEPS (USD)Dividend YieldROE (%)ROA (%)Piotroski F-Score
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.0.2012.071.6661,952N/A14.656.395
UnitedHealth Group Inc.0.6022.505.5021.501.40%25.008.007
MetLife Inc.0.298.000.9010.053.00%11.501.206
Prudential Financial Inc.0.349.500.8511.404.50%9.000.905
The Progressive Corporation0.3313.503.1021.000.40%23.005.008
The Travelers Companies Inc.0.2611.001.5023.702.00%13.503.006
Allstate Corporation0.2810.001.2020.752.20%12.002.507

Key Analysis:

  • Debt/Equity Ratio: All companies maintain conservative debt levels, with ratios below 0.60, indicating prudent financial management.
  • P/E Ratio: UnitedHealth Group has the highest P/E ratio at 22.50, suggesting higher growth expectations. In contrast, MetLife’s P/E of 8.00 may indicate undervaluation.
  • P/B Ratio: UnitedHealth Group’s P/B ratio of 5.50 reflects strong market valuation relative to its book value, whereas MetLife and Prudential Financial have P/B ratios below 1, potentially signaling undervaluation.
  • EPS: Berkshire Hathaway’s EPS is notably high due to its diversified conglomerate structure.
  • Dividend Yield: Prudential Financial offers the highest dividend yield at 4.50%, appealing to income-focused investors.
  • ROE & ROA: UnitedHealth Group and The Progressive Corporation exhibit robust profitability metrics, with high ROE and ROA figures.
  • Piotroski F-Score: The Progressive Corporation leads with a score of 8, indicating strong financial health.

Piotroski Score for Each Insurance Company

CompanyProfitability (4)Liquidity & Leverage (3)Efficiency (2)Total F-Score (Max 9)
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.3115
UnitedHealth Group Inc.4217
MetLife Inc.3216
Prudential Financial Inc.3115
The Progressive Corporation4318
The Travelers Companies Inc.3216
Allstate Corporation4217

Piotroski Score Interpretation

  • Score 8: The Progressive Corporation has the strongest fundamentals, with positive profitability, improving liquidity, and strong efficiency metrics.
  • Score 7: UnitedHealth Group & Allstate Corporation also show solid financial health, but with minor weaknesses in leverage or efficiency.
  • Score 6: MetLife & Travelers Companies have moderate financial strength but some concerns in liquidity or profitability.
  • Score 5: Berkshire Hathaway & Prudential Financial show moderate financial health, with weaknesses in leverage or efficiency.

Investment Insights from Piotroski Score

  1. High Piotroski Score (7-9): Progressive, UnitedHealth, and Allstate are financially strong and good long-term investment candidates.
  2. Moderate Score (5-6): MetLife, Travelers, Berkshire Hathaway, and Prudential are stable but need deeper analysis for specific weaknesses.
  3. Low Score (0-3): (None in this case) Would indicate high-risk companies with weak fundamentals.

Concluding this article :

Investment Rationale and Credit Ratings of Major U.S. Insurance Companies

Investing in insurance companies requires evaluating their financial stability, market position, innovation, and future growth potential. Below is an overview of why these companies are good investments, followed by their credit ratings and an analysis of their bullish or bearish outlook.


Why These Insurance Companies Are Good Investments

CompanyReasons to Invest
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.– Diversified Portfolio: Investments in multiple industries help reduce risk. 
– Strong Cash Reserves: The company holds significant cash reserves, ensuring financial flexibility. 
– Smart Capital Allocation: Led by Warren Buffett, known for making high-return investments.
UnitedHealth Group Inc.– Market Leader: Largest U.S. health insurance company with growing revenue. 
– Expanding Services: Increasing presence in healthcare services and technology. 
– Strong Profit Margins: Consistently generates high earnings.
MetLife Inc.– Global Presence: Operates in over 40 countries, reducing dependency on any single market. 
– Growing Digital Initiatives: Enhancing customer experience through technology. 
– Steady Dividend Payouts: Offers consistent returns to shareholders.
Prudential Financial Inc.– Well-Diversified Business Model: Includes insurance, asset management, and retirement services. 
– Strong Brand Recognition: Trusted name in the financial sector. 
– Focus on International Growth: Expanding in Asian and Latin American markets.
The Progressive Corporation– Technology-Driven Growth: Leader in digital insurance policies and AI-driven risk assessment. 
– Consistently Growing Market Share: Strong position in auto insurance. 
– Efficient Cost Management: Maintains high profitability through data-driven decision-making.
The Travelers Companies Inc.– Strong Commercial Insurance Portfolio: Covers businesses, reducing reliance on personal auto/home insurance. 
– Stable Financials: Maintains a conservative risk profile and strong capital reserves. 
– Steady Dividend Growth: Regularly increases payouts to investors.
Allstate Corporation– Strong Market Position in Auto & Home Insurance: Large customer base ensures stable revenue. 
– Investment in Digital Services: Improving claims processing and customer experience through technology. 
– Competitive Pricing Strategies: Helps attract and retain policyholders.

Credit Ratings & Market Sentiment for Insurance Companies

CompanyCredit Rating (S&P/Moody’s/Fitch)Bullish or Bearish?Reason for Sentiment
Berkshire Hathaway Inc.AA+ / Aa2 / AA+NeutralWell-diversified, but insurance segment faces some risk from climate-related claims.
UnitedHealth Group Inc.AA / Aa3 / AA-BullishStrong growth in health insurance and expansion in digital healthcare.
MetLife Inc.AA- / A1 / AA-NeutralSolid financials, but interest rate fluctuations can impact growth.
Prudential Financial Inc.A+ / A2 / A+NeutralExpanding globally but faces headwinds from economic downturns.
The Progressive CorporationAA / Aa2 / AABullishLeading auto insurer with innovative pricing models and strong profitability.
The Travelers Companies Inc.AA / Aa2 / AANeutralConsistent performance but faces exposure to natural disaster risks.
Allstate CorporationAA- / A1 / AA-BullishStrong digital transformation efforts and solid revenue growth.

Analysis of Credit Ratings & Future Sentiment

  1. Bullish Companies:
    • UnitedHealth Group: Leading the way in healthcare expansion, making it a strong long-term bet.
    • Progressive: Best positioned for auto insurance growth, especially with its AI-driven underwriting models.
    • Allstate: Investing heavily in digital transformation, making its future more promising.
  2. Neutral Companies:
    • Berkshire Hathaway: Strong overall, but its insurance division may face climate-related challenges.
    • MetLife & Prudential: Stable performers, but dependent on interest rate policies that impact investment income.
    • Travelers: Well-managed, but exposed to unpredictable risks like natural disasters.

Final Thoughts

  • Investors seeking stable, long-term returns should consider UnitedHealth, Progressive, and Allstate as bullish options.
  • For conservative investorsBerkshire Hathaway, Travelers, and MetLife offer steady growth with lower risk.
  • Market fluctuations, interest rate changes, and regulatory shifts will play a key role in the future of these insurance giants.

I hope you liked this article

Happy Investing

More Blogs :

  1. Open Letters
  2. Health related Blogs that you don’t want to miss

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Buy Me A Coffee
Thank you for visiting. You can now buy me a coffee!